Garden of Life Raw Organic Protein Review

Name: Raw Organic Protein
Brand: Garden of Life

Once a gold standard in organic supplements, now facing serious credibility issues. Active class action lawsuit over lead contamination. Consumer Reports found 564% over Prop 65 lead limit in Sport Or

By Alec & Michael•9 min read

✓ Updated Apr 20263.9/10 Score

Raw Organic Protein. Our #1 rated protein after testing.

#1 Rated Protein

Raw Organic Protein

★★★★★3.9 / 10

Once a gold standard in organic supplements, now facing serious credibility issues. Active class action lawsuit over lead contamination.

Formulation Quality

5.5

Testing & Transparency

$3.15/serving

Detailed Scoring

Evident Ratings

Raw Organic Protein

Based on hands-on testing + review analysis Compared across protein brands

3.9

out of 10

Formulation Quality

5.5

Testing & Transparency

Price per strip: $3.15/serving

Our Findings

What We Found

What we liked

Third-party tested (NSF Contents Certified)

No gums or thickeners

No soy lecithin

USDA Organic certified

No added sugar

Our concerns

Has active or recent lawsuits

Premium price ($3.15/serving)

Our Verdict

Once a gold standard in organic supplements, now facing serious credibility issues. Active class action lawsuit over lead contamination.

See Best Protein Powder →

Get our latest research

New reviews and sleep science insights — no spam, ever.

Keep Reading

More on Protein

Grass-Fed Whey Protein Isolate

AGN Roots Grass-Fed Whey Protein Isolate Review

Organic Vegan Protein

Transparent Labs Organic Vegan Protein Review

USDA Organic Grass-Fed Whey Protein

Raw Organic Whey USDA Organic Grass-Fed Whey Protein Review

Garden of Life

Raw Organic Protein

Independently researched and scored by EvidentHigh confidence

3.9

Overall

Material & Safety

2.8

Trust & Reputation

Value & Policy

Features

Firsthand Testing

4.5

Material & Safety

Third-Party Testing

NSF Contents CertifiedVerified

COA Availability

Not availableClaimed

Heavy Metals Testing

Consumer Reports found 2.82 ug lead/serving in Sport Organic line (564% over Prop 65 limit). One of the worst performers tested.Verified

USDA Organic

YesVerified

Trust & Reputation

Amazon Rating

4.4 (30,000 reviews)Verified

Amino Acid Profile Disclosed

YesVerified

Red Flags

Active class action lawsuit (filed Dec 2025) alleging false safety advertising due to lead contamination. Prior Prop 65 Notice of Violation (April 2020). NSF Contents Certified is weaker than NSF Certified for Sport — may mislead consumers. Owned by Nestle since 2017.Verified

Value & Policy

Price

~$3.15/servingVerified

Price Per Serving

$3.15Verified

Servings Per Container

20Verified

Return Policy

60-day satisfaction guarantee from date of purchase (gardenoflife.com orders only). RMA number required. Refund to original payment method.Claimed

Subscription

Subscribe & Save: 15% off first 4 orders, 20% off all subsequent orders. Free shipping. Delivery every 30, 45, 60, or 90 days.Claimed

Features

Natural Flavors

Contains: Flavored variants (Chocolate, Vanilla, Vanilla Chai) contain natural flavors. Chocolate ingredient list includes 'organic flavor blend: organic chocolate flavors with other natural flavors'. Unflavored variant does NOT contain natural flavors. Status is false because the majority of SKUs (3 of 4 flavors) contain natural flavors.

Gums

NoneVerified

Soy Lecithin

NoneVerified

Added Sugar

NoneVerified

Sweetener

Stevia (flavored), None (unflavored)Verified

Protein Source Category

Plant-BasedVerified

Protein Source

Mixed Plant BlendVerified

Made In

USAClaimed

GMP Certified

YesVerified

Manufacturing Location

USAClaimed

Background

Founded in 2000 by Jordan Rubin. Acquired by Nestle in 2017 for ~$2.3 billion. One of the largest organic supplement brands in the US. Known for sprouted, raw, organic formulations. The Nestle acquisition and subsequent contamination revelations have damaged the brand's trust with health-conscious consumers.

Full category comparison

Best Protein Powder →